Unexpected Heroes: Outfield Players Turned Goalkeepers in MLS History

In a surprising turn of events this weekend, Columbus Crew midfielder Sean Zawadzki found himself in the goalkeeper’s role against the Seattle Sounders. After starting goalkeeper Abraham Romero received a red card in stoppage time of the first half, and with no backup goalkeeper available, Zawadzki stepped up to defend the net. Despite his best efforts, the Crew fell 4-0 to the Sounders.

This unexpected scenario brings to mind other memorable instances in Major League Soccer history where outfield players have had to don the gloves and take on the role of goalkeeper. Let’s take a look at some of these unforgettable moments.

Nick Downing for New England Revolution (2001)

In a 2001 match, New England Revolution’s Nick Downing had to play as goalkeeper after their starting goalkeeper was sent off. Downing’s unexpected role showcased the unpredictable nature of soccer and the importance of team spirit and adaptability.

Eddie Gaven for NYRB (2003)

In a match against D.C. United in 2003, 16-year-old Eddie Gaven became the youngest goalkeeper in MLS history. After goalkeeper Tim Howard was sent off, Gaven was substituted in as a goalkeeper due to a loophole in the substitution rules. He quickly swapped positions with Howard and later scored the game-winning goal in overtime.

Eddie Gaven for Columbus Crew (2011)

Eddie Gaven found himself in goal again in 2011 while playing for the Columbus Crew. During a match against the Philadelphia Union, goalkeeper William Hesmer was injured, and Gaven stepped in as the goalkeeper for the final minutes. Although brief, this instance highlighted Gaven’s willingness to step up for his team.

Mike Magee for LA Galaxy (2011)

On June 25, 2011, LA Galaxy’s starting goalkeeper Donovan Ricketts was injured, and backup Josh Saunders received a red card. Midfielder Mike Magee was called upon to play as goalkeeper against the San Jose Earthquakes. Magee made several crucial saves, helping his team secure a 0-0 draw. His performance earned him the nickname “Magee the Keeper”.

Ryan Hollingshead for FC Dallas (2016)

In a 2016 match against Toronto FC, FC Dallas found themselves without a goalkeeper after Chris Seitz was sent off. Defender Ryan Hollingshead took over the goalkeeping duties for the remainder of the match. Despite the unusual situation, Hollingshead managed to keep a clean sheet, showcasing his versatility and composure under pressure.

Jalil Anibaba for Houston Dynamo (2016)

Houston Dynamo’s goalkeeper Joe Willis was sent off against the SJ Earthquakes in 2016. Defender Jalil Anibaba (who Crew fans may know from his time with the Black and Gold in 2022) took over the goalkeeping duties for the remainder of the match. Despite the challenging situation, Anibaba’s efforts were commendable, demonstrating his versatility and commitment to the team.

Rodrigo Schlegel for Orlando City (2020)

During the 2020 MLS Cup Playoffs, Orlando City’s goalkeeper Pedro Gallese received a second yellow card during a penalty shootout against New York City FC. With no substitutions left, defender Rodrigo Schlegel stepped in as goalkeeper. Schlegel made a crucial save in the shootout, helping Orlando City advance to the next round in a dramatic and chaotic match.

These unforgettable moments remind us that soccer is not just about skill and strategy but also about heart and determination. The instances where outfield players had to play as goalkeepers due to red cards or injuries are a testament to the unpredictable and thrilling game that is soccer.